Chapter 10 : Shared Pointers, An Introduction To Atomics In C++

Key words: Shared Pointers in C++, Implementing a custom shared_ptr in C++, Atomics in C++

Topics at a glance:

Sharing ownership via Shared Pointers and their need
Atomics in Shared pointer

In this chapter, I will show you how to make a custom Shared_Ptr from our Chapter 9’s Unique_Ptr using C++’s atomics.

Shared Pointers in C++

Shared Pointers using template specialization and C++ atomics

We have seen how to implement our own Unique_Ptr class using template specialization. Unique_Ptr’s only support move semantics and no copy operation is allowed. Of course the sole purpose of Unique_Ptr is to avoid multiple owners for the same memory region at any given point of time. Using move you can only transfer ownership of memory through a Unique_Ptr. What if you want shared ownership? Then we need to use C++’s 2^nd smart pointer i.e. the ‘std::shared_ptr’. Shared pointers allow multiple ownership achieved through two things:

Shared pointers allow copy semantics (obviously)
Shared pointers uses a reference count (use count) mechanism that tracks the current number of owners that uses the shared memory region
Shared pointers will delete/release the memory back to free store only if the reference count reaches 0.

So, that is how shared pointers work.

Implementing a custom shared_ptr in C++

Now, to implement our shared pointer, let us use the Unique_Ptr code from previous chapter and rename ‘Unique_Ptr’ to ‘Shared_Ptr’. Not only that. We will need to introduce a reference counter. Reference counter cannot be a local count data to Shared_Ptr object instances as after copying the ownership Shared_Ptr should use the exact same instance of reference count to track the owners in all copies of Shared_Ptr objects.

This bring another issue. Unlike old generation computers and OS’s all modern CPU’s support actual multi-threading and parallel computing. So there can be multiple threads sharing ownership of memory through instances of Shared_Ptr’s. This will result in data race condition. And reference count is likely to be changed from different threads simultaneously. Reference count is the only thing that matters for Shared_Ptrs to delete pointer and release back the memory. So it is imperative to protect reference count from data race conditions associated with multi-threaded environments. How to do that?

Atomics in C++

C++ gives some essential facilities to deal with issues inherent to multi-threaded environments. One we can consider here is mutex lock (mutually exclusive lock), and other is atomics. I prefer atomics here. Mutex is very difficult to apply here. As who will take care of releasing the mutex itself at the end of Shared Pointer’s life-cycle. The same mutex needs to be used for the same reference count in case of shared ownership. So why to go for all such headaches. Let us use the simple atomics. Atomics guarantees completion of execution of any operation without interruption. We’ll use C++’s std::atomic for defining the reference counter in our Shared_Ptr. So I will point out once again the key features to be implemented on Unique_Ptr to make it a Shared_Ptr class.

From Unique_Ptr to Shared_Ptr code modification:

Replace Unique_Ptr to Shared_Ptr
Define copy operations
Implement an atomic reference count member that could be shared between copies of Shared_Ptr instances
Define a use_count() member function that will return the current value of reference count

That’s it. Now, with all this information, let us implement Shared_Ptr. NOTE: For now, I am not defining any custom make_shared as we did for Unique_Ptrs. Let us use the basic new operation for constructing objects and pass the returned pointers to make Shared_Ptr instances.

Also note that I have retained all the default and custom deleters that I have used in Unique_Ptr.

Please go through the detailed and elaborated code below, and understand how the points discussed above are actually implemented.

#include <iostream>
#include <atomic>

using namespace std;

// single object deleter version 
template<typename T>
struct default_deleter // default_deleter is a functor or function object 
{    
    // don't have any private/public/protected data 
    void operator()(T* ptr)
    {
        if(ptr != nullptr) // this check is very important 
        {
            cout << "default_deleter" << endl;
            // default deleter is as good as a 
            // direct delete on the pointer. 
            // There cannot be any custom cleanup here.  
            delete ptr;
        }
    }
};

// Array deleter version
template<typename T>
struct default_deleter<T[]> // default_deleter is a functor or function object 
{    
    // don't have any private/public/protected data 
    void operator()(T* ptr)
    {
        if(ptr != nullptr) // this check is very important 
        {
            cout << "default_deleter [] " << endl;
            // default deleter is as good as a 
            // direct delete on the pointer. 
            // There cannot be any custom cleanup here.  
            delete []ptr;
        }
    }
};

// An example of default template type. 
// TP's default 'type' is default_deleter<T>
// If provided, a custom deleter TP, user can either 
// install a functor object or it can be a simple
// function pointer which accepts a pointer parameter. 
template< typename T, typename TP = default_deleter<T> >
class Shared_Ptr
{
private:
    std::atomic<int*> reference_count;
    T* raw_ptr;
    TP deleter; // will get constructed anyways with default_deleter type  
public:
    explicit Shared_Ptr(T* object) : 
        raw_ptr{object}, 
        reference_count(new int(1)) // cannot use {}, use ()
    {
        cout << "Shared_Ptr created with Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
    }
    
    // constructor which accepts a custom deleter 
    Shared_Ptr(T* object, TP custom_deleter) : 
        raw_ptr{object}, 
        deleter{custom_deleter}, 
        reference_count(new int(1)) // cannot use {}, use ()
    {
        cout << "Shared_Ptr created with Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
    }
    
    ~Shared_Ptr()
    {
        if(reference_count != nullptr)
        {
            --(*reference_count);
            cout << "In Shared_Ptr Destructor Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
            if(*reference_count <= 0)
            {
                if(raw_ptr != nullptr)
                {
                    // call deleter
                    deleter(raw_ptr);
                }
            }
        }
    }
    
    TP& get_deleter()
    {
        return deleter;
    }
    
    // define copy operations
    Shared_Ptr(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        // do not create a new reference_count, copy the pointer from other_shared_ptr
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        if(reference_count != nullptr)
        {
            ++(*reference_count);
            cout << "In Shared_Ptr Copy Constructor Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
        }
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter;
    }
    
    Shared_Ptr& operator=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        // do not create a new reference_count, copy the pointer from other_shared_ptr
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        if(reference_count != nullptr)
        {
            ++(*reference_count);
            cout << "In Shared_Ptr Copy =operator Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
        }
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter;
        
        return *this;
    }
    
    // Define move operations
    Shared_Ptr(Shared_Ptr&& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        // transfer the ownership of memory 
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr = nullptr;
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        other_shared_ptr.reference_count = nullptr;
        
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter;        
    }
    
    Shared_Ptr& operator=(Shared_Ptr&& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        // transfer the ownership of memory 
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr = nullptr;
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        other_shared_ptr.reference_count = nullptr;
        
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter;
        
        return *this;
    }
    
    // define basic operations supported by a regular pointer
    // 1. dereference operation
    T& operator*() const 
    {
        return *raw_ptr;
    }
    
    // 2. member selection operation
    T* operator->() const 
    {
        return raw_ptr;
    }
    
    // 3. indexing operation ( ONLY for array version ) 
    /*T& operator[](const int index)
    {
        return raw_ptr[index];
    }*/
    
    // 4. equality check 
    bool operator==(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr == other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }
    
    // 5. in-equality check 
    bool operator!=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return!(this->operator==(other_shared_ptr));
    }
    
    // 6. less than 
    bool operator<(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr < other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }
    
    // 7. greater than 
    bool operator>(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return!(this->operator<(other_shared_ptr));
    }    
    
    // 8. less than or equal  
    bool operator<=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr <= other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }
    
    // 9. greater than or equal 
    bool operator>=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr >= other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }    
    
    T* get() const 
    {
        return raw_ptr;
    }
    
    explicit operator bool() const 
    {
        return (raw_ptr != nullptr);
    }
    
    T* release()
    {
        T* temp = raw_ptr;
        raw_ptr = nullptr;
        reference_count = nullptr;
        
        return temp;
    }
    
    void reset(T* new_ptr)
    {
        T* old_ptr =  raw_ptr;
        raw_ptr = new_ptr;
        reference_count = 1; // reset back to 1
        
        if(old_ptr != nullptr)
        {
            deleter(old_ptr); 
        }
    }
    
    int use_count() const 
    {
        return *reference_count;
    }
    
};

// Array version T[] with custom deleter support 
template< typename T, typename TP > // Here TP already has the default type as default_deleter<T>
class Shared_Ptr<T[], TP> // Must have Shared_Ptr<T> already defined for T[] to work 
{
private:
    std::atomic<int*> reference_count;
    T * raw_ptr; // pointer to an array of T's
    TP deleter;
public:
    Shared_Ptr(T *object) : 
        raw_ptr{object}, 
        deleter{default_deleter<T[]>()}, // Here we copy-construct specialized deleter<T[]>
        reference_count(new int(1)) // cannot use {}, use ()
    {
        cout << "Shared_Ptr [] created with Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
    }
    
    Shared_Ptr(T* object, TP this_deleter): 
        raw_ptr{object}, deleter{this_deleter}, 
        reference_count(new int(1)) // cannot use {}, use ()
    {
        cout << "Shared_Ptr [] created with Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
    }
    
    ~Shared_Ptr()
    {
        if(reference_count != nullptr)
        {
            --(*reference_count);
            cout << "Shared_Ptr [] destructor Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
            if(*reference_count == 0)
            {
                if(raw_ptr != nullptr)
                {
                    deleter(raw_ptr);
                }
            }
        }
    }
    
    TP& get_deleter()
    {
        return deleter;
    }
    
    // define copy operations
    Shared_Ptr(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        
        if(raw_ptr != nullptr)
        {
            ++(*reference_count);
        }
        
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter;
        
        cout << "In Shared_Ptr [] Copy constructor Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
        
    }
    
    Shared_Ptr& operator=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        
        if(raw_ptr != nullptr)
        {
            ++(*reference_count);
        }
        
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter;
        
        cout << "In Shared_Ptr [] Copy =operator Ref count : " << *reference_count << endl;
        
        return *this;
    }
    
    // Define move operations
    Shared_Ptr(Shared_Ptr&& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        // transfer the ownership of memory 
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr = nullptr;
        
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter; 
        
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        other_shared_ptr.reference_count = nullptr;
        
    }
    
    Shared_Ptr& operator=(Shared_Ptr&& other_shared_ptr)
    {
        // transfer the ownership of memory 
        raw_ptr = other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr;
        other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr = nullptr;
        
        deleter = other_shared_ptr.deleter; 
        
        reference_count = other_shared_ptr.reference_count.load();
        other_shared_ptr.reference_count = nullptr;
        
        return *this;
    }
    
    // define basic operations supported by a regular pointer
    // 1. dereference operation
    T& operator*() const 
    {
        return *raw_ptr;
    }
    
    // 2. member selection operation
    T* operator->() const 
    {
        return raw_ptr;
    }
    
    // 3. indexing operation ( ONLY for array version ) 
    T& operator[](const int index)
    {
        return raw_ptr[index];
    }
    
    // 4. equality check 
    bool operator==(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr == other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }
    
    // 5. in-equality check 
    bool operator!=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return!(this->operator==(other_shared_ptr));
    }
    
    // 6. less than 
    bool operator<(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr < other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }
    
    // 7. greater than 
    bool operator>(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return!(this->operator<(other_shared_ptr));
    }    
    
    // 8. less than or equal  
    bool operator<=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr <= other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }
    
    // 9. greater than or equal 
    bool operator>=(const Shared_Ptr& other_shared_ptr) const 
    {
        return(raw_ptr >= other_shared_ptr.raw_ptr);
    }    
    
    T* get() const 
    {
        return raw_ptr;
    }
    
    explicit operator bool() const 
    {
        return (raw_ptr != nullptr);
    }
    
    T* release()
    {
        T* temp = raw_ptr;
        raw_ptr = nullptr;
        reference_count = nullptr;
        
        return temp;
    }
    
    void reset(T* new_ptr)
    {
        T* old_ptr =  raw_ptr;
        raw_ptr = new_ptr;
        reference_count = 1; // reset back to 1
        
        if(old_ptr != nullptr)
        {
            deleter(old_ptr);
        }
    }
    
    int use_count() const 
    {
        return *reference_count;
    }
    
};

// A custom deleter 
struct Custom_Deleter
{
    void operator()(int* ptr)
    {
        if(ptr != nullptr)
        {
            cout << "Custom deleter" << endl;
            // do some other cleanup if any
            delete ptr;
        }
    }
};

// A generic template based custom deleter 
template<typename G> // G for generic :) (kidding)
struct Generic_Custom_Deleter
{
private:
    // NOTE: The count_ is just used to identify the 
    // Generic_Custom_Deleter that is called 
    // when a user changes the deleter after 
    // the Shared_Ptr has been already created
    int count_;
public:
    Generic_Custom_Deleter(int count = 0): count_{count} {}
    void operator()(G* ptr)
    {
        if(ptr != nullptr)
        {
            cout << "Generic Custom deleter - " << count_ << endl;
            // do some other cleanup if any
            delete ptr;
        }
    }
};

// A function type deleter 
void deleter_function(int* ptr)
{
    if(ptr != nullptr)
    {
        cout << "Function deleter" << endl;
        // do some other cleanup if any
        delete ptr;
    }
    
    return;
}

struct Custom_Array_Deleter
{
    void operator()(int *ptr)
    {
        if(ptr != nullptr)
        {
            cout << "Custom_Array_Deleter" << endl;
            delete[] ptr; // see the array version of delete[] used here 
        }
        
        return;
    }
};

int main()
{   
    {
        Shared_Ptr<int> sh_ptr1(new int); 
        // local scope 1
        {
            Shared_Ptr<int> sh_ptr2 = sh_ptr1; // copy construction 
            *sh_ptr2 = 5;
        }
        
        cout << "Outside local scope 1" << endl;
        cout << "*shptr1 : " << *sh_ptr1 << endl;
    
    }
    
    cout << endl;
    
    {
        const int size = 10;
        Shared_Ptr<int[]> sh_ptr3(new int[size]); 
        // local scope 2
        {
            Shared_Ptr<int[]> sh_ptr4 = sh_ptr3; // copy construction 
            for(int index = 0; index < size; ++index)
            {
                sh_ptr4[index] = index*10;
            }
        }
        
        cout << "Outside local scope 2" << endl;
        
        for(int index = 0; index < size; ++index)
        {
            cout << "sh_ptr3[" << index << "] : " << sh_ptr3[index] << endl;
        }
    }
    
    return 0;
}

I will explain later why we have to use normal parantheses () instead of curly braces {}, way of construction for atomic reference count, also, why to use load () while copying atomic variables. For now, just focus on the working of shared pointers.

Let us see how reference count actually tracks the shared ownership. I have purposefully defined local scopes in the main() to show how reference count is checked by the Shared_Ptr’s destructor before deleting the pointer and releasing the memory.

Let us see the result now:

Shared_Ptr created with Ref count : 1
In Shared_Ptr Copy Constructor Ref count : 2
In Shared_Ptr Destructor Ref count : 1
Outside local scope 1
*shptr1 : 5
In Shared_Ptr Destructor Ref count : 0
default_deleter
Shared_Ptr [] created with Ref count : 1
In Shared_Ptr [] Copy constructor Ref count : 2
Shared_Ptr [] destructor Ref count : 1
Outside local scope 2
sh_ptr3[0] : 0
sh_ptr3[1] : 10
sh_ptr3[2] : 20
sh_ptr3[3] : 30
sh_ptr3[4] : 40
sh_ptr3[5] : 50
sh_ptr3[6] : 60
sh_ptr3[7] : 70
sh_ptr3[8] : 80
sh_ptr3[9] : 90
Shared_Ptr [] destructor Ref count : 0
default_deleter []

Try to track the reference count of shared Shared_Ptr instances and see when the actual delete is getting called.

The thread safety of shared pointers are to be discussed further. The standard only guarantees atomic operations on the reference count of the shared pointer and not on the object itself that shared pointer points to. I have only made the reference count as atomic here.

Enjoyed the chapter? Let me know in the comments below. Thanks! 🙂

2 thoughts on “Chapter 10 : Shared Pointers, An Introduction To Atomics In C++”

Daya Shanker Prasad says:

December 3, 2020 at 11:51 pm

There are many bugs in your shared_ptr implementation. Starting with the simplest

Shared_Ptr ptr{nullptr};

Why do you want ref_count even with the value of 1 should exist? Ideally it shouldn’t.

Additionally your content requires more than 50% width of screen but you allocated approx 30% of screen width. It gives pain.

I don’t think, people love to watch all the code at once but relevant part at once.

1. Deepesh Menon says:
  
  December 4, 2020 at 8:34 am
  
  Hi Daya, I will look into the issues you have pointed out. Thanks for your review

The C and C++ Club

Let's Learn Together! :)

Chapter 10 : Shared Pointers, An Introduction To Atomics In C++

Shared Pointers in C++

Implementing a custom shared_ptr in C++

Atomics in C++

2 thoughts on “Chapter 10 : Shared Pointers, An Introduction To Atomics In C++”

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

Shared Pointers in C++

Implementing a custom shared_ptr in C++

Atomics in C++

Share this:

2 thoughts on “Chapter 10 : Shared Pointers, An Introduction To Atomics In C++”

Leave a ReplyCancel reply